The glenoid has travelled some number of degrees from where it started. The reamer can bring back ten to fifteen of them before you are medialising into the vault. The difference between those two numbers decides the case, and it is the number that usually goes unwritten: it is what tells you whether this is a standard glenoid, an augment, or a reverse.
Budget this glenoid → The hip instrument →The knee measures opening across flexion and the hip measures tilt across posture. The shoulder measures something static: how far the glenoid has eroded away from the premorbid surface it started as. That premorbid glenoid, reconstructed from the vault, is this joint's fixed reference.
This is where the shoulder genuinely differs from the knee and the hip. Those two are decided by geometry. The shoulder has a soft-tissue gate sitting above the geometry: an incompetent cuff sends the case to a reverse no matter how correctable the glenoid is. The budget matters underneath that gate, not above it.
Centred head, version near premorbid, cuff intact. A standard glenoid on an anatomic reconstruction. The Walch A shoulder is the one that behaves.
The Walch classification →Deformity inside the safe limit and inside the threshold where most surgeons still ream rather than augment. Anatomic, with the version corrected on the way in.
Eccentric reaming for posterior wear →Correcting this much by reaming alone medialises into the vault. An augmented baseplate or graft carries the correction the reamer should not. Anatomic only if the cuff is genuinely intact and the residual is small.
Vault perforation after eccentric reaming →Anatomic reconstruction on a B2 glenoid carries about a 10.5% complication rate, most often recurrent posterior subluxation, even where revision stays near 2.4%. When the numbers do not close, the reverse is the honest answer.
Anatomic versus reverse for B2 →| Knee | Hip | Shoulder | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The envelope | Compartment opening under load, across flexion | Functional pelvic tilt, across posture | Distance travelled from the premorbid glenoid |
| The fixed reference | Constitutional alignment | Pelvic incidence | Premorbid (paleo) glenoid |
| Position first | Component angles inside the alignment boundaries | Cup anteversion inside the functional window | Eccentric reaming inside the safe limit |
| The residual | Laxity positioning cannot balance | Postures no cup orientation satisfies | Degrees the reamer should not take |
| The escalation | Conformity, lip, step | Dual mobility | Augment, graft, or reverse |
| Mandatory episode | TEAM | TEAM | none |
The measurements above are attached. Contact details only; we reply with the ledger format and the other two instruments.
Stored as telemetry for calibration, not as a clinical record. No patient identifiers are collected.